- Senator Alex Padilla (D-CA) and Representative Joe Morelle (D-NY) have called for the reinstatement of officials at CISA placed on administrative leave by the Trump administration, citing threats to election security.
- Critics argue that CISA’s involvement in monitoring and flagging speech for suppression raises concerns about free speech, with some viewing it as necessary to prevent government overreach in online discourse.
- The debate over CISA’s role is part of a broader trend where government agencies and social media companies have collaborated to monitor and control online speech, particularly during the 2020 election.
- Meta has announced changes to its content moderation policies, moving away from third-party fact-checking and towards a community-based notes system, which is seen as a step towards protecting free speech online.
- Congress is encouraged to pass the Protecting Speech from Government Interference Act to prevent politically motivated censorship and reinforce First Amendment protections, ensuring a balance between election security and free expression.
(Natural News)—In a controversial move, Senator Alex Padilla (D-CA) and Representative Joe Morelle (D-NY) are demanding the reinstatement of officials within the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) who were placed on administrative leave by the Trump administration. These lawmakers, known for their strong advocacy of government intervention in online discourse, argue that the removal of these employees threatens election security. However, their push to restore these officials has raised significant concerns among free speech advocates and conservative critics.
CISA’s role in election security: A double-edged sword
In a formal letter to CISA, Senator Padilla and Representative Morelle expressed their alarm over the removal of employees who were involved in monitoring and flagging speech for suppression. They wrote, “Election-related mis- and disinformation from domestic and foreign actors continues to threaten the strength and integrity of our democracy by weakening trust in our elections and promoting falsehoods about election officials that have resulted in threats against them and their families.”
While the lawmakers frame their concerns in the context of election security, critics argue that this rhetoric is a familiar justification for empowering government agencies to police online speech. The Trump administration’s decision to sideline these officials is seen by some as a necessary course correction to prevent federal agencies from overstepping their bounds in surveilling and controlling public discourse.
Historical context: A pattern of censorship
The current debate over CISA’s role is not isolated. It is part of a broader trend where government agencies and social media platforms have increasingly collaborated to monitor and control online speech. This collaboration reached a peak during the 2020 presidential election, when Twitter, under the leadership of former executives Vijaya Gadde, James Baker and Yoel Roth, worked closely with the FBI to censor content, particularly the New York Post’s story about the Biden family’s business dealings.
In a recent hearing of the House Committee on Oversight and Accountability, former Twitter executives admitted that the New York Post’s Hunter Biden laptop story did not violate any of the company’s policies but was censored nonetheless. Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.) emphasized, “Isn’t it correct that the Biden campaign had contact with Twitter in the run-up to the 2020 election… And you’re telling this committee that you didn’t ask any Biden representative if the laptop was real or for Hunter Biden’s attorney’s phone number to confirm its authenticity?”
Rep. Andy Biggs (R-Ariz.) echoed this sentiment, noting that Twitter executives were openly hostile towards conservative voices and specifically targeted the New York Post’s Hunter Biden laptop story. “Within mere minutes or hours after the New York Post published its story on the Hunter Biden laptop, at 8:51 am, you sent a message to a team, part of your team I assume. You said, ‘It isn’t clearly violative of our hacked materials policy,’ referring to the story, ‘nor is it clearly in violation of anything else.’ Do you remember sending that message?” Mr. Roth responded, “I don’t recall that message specifically, but that does sound like my judgment on that day, yes.”
Meta’s reset: A beacon of hope for free speech
While the Democrats push to restore government control over online speech, a significant counter-movement is emerging. Meta, the parent company of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, has announced a major reform in its content moderation policies. CEO Mark Zuckerberg acknowledged that the pendulum of content control had swung too far, leading to excessive censorship and mistakes.
Zuckerberg’s decision to abandon the third-party fact-checking system in the U.S. and move toward a community-based notes system, similar to what Elon Musk implemented at X (formerly Twitter), represents a more democratic approach to content contextualization. This move is seen as a crucial step in restoring balance and protecting free speech online.
Amy Bos, Director of State and Federal Affairs, praised Meta’s reforms, stating, “This kind of innovation in content moderation would be impossible without America’s unique environment of free enterprise and free expression. Meta’s reset offers hope that we can maintain vibrant online spaces without sacrificing our commitment to free expression.”
The need for legislative action
To protect these gains and prevent future government overreach, Congress should reintroduce and pass the Protecting Speech from Government Interference Act. This legislation, championed by Chairs James Comer, Jim Jordan and Cathy McMorris Rodgers, would prevent politically motivated bureaucrats from coercing private businesses to suppress lawful speech. By reinforcing the First Amendment’s protections and preventing covert censorship, this act is essential for preserving a marketplace of ideas where speech can be freely exchanged.
As we navigate the complexities of the digital age, it is crucial to strike a balance between maintaining election security and upholding the principles of free speech. The ongoing debate over CISA’s role and Meta’s recent reforms highlight the importance of vigilance and proactive legislation to ensure that government control over online speech does not undermine the very foundations of American democracy.
Sources include:
It’s becoming increasingly clear that fiat currencies across the globe, including the U.S. Dollar, are under attack. Paper money is losing its value, translating into insane inflation and less value in our life’s savings.
Genesis Gold Group believes physical precious metals are an amazing option for those seeking to move their wealth or retirement to higher ground. Whether Central Bank Digital Currencies replace current fiat currencies or not, precious metals are poised to retain or even increase in value. This is why central banks and mega-asset managers like BlackRock are moving much of their holdings to precious metals.
As a Christian company, Genesis Gold Group has maintained a perfect 5 out of 5 rating with the Better Business Bureau. Their faith-driven values allow them to help Americans protect their life’s savings without the gimmicks used by most precious metals companies. Reach out to them today to see how they can streamline the rollover or transfer of your current and previous retirement accounts.
Kamala Harris Says the American Dream Is “Gone”
by Modernity News
During a pre recorded interview, Kamala Harris once again failed to deliver any substantive outline of her policies, primarily attacking Donald Trump’s outlook and his first term in office. At one point when speaking about the economy, Harris appeared to suggest, in stark contrast to Trump, that the American Dream…
Gold Price Forecasts Skyrocket Following Moves by China and the Fed
by Sponsored Post
With the Federal Reserve beginning what most expect to be a sustained easing cycle, momentum continues to rise for gold and silver. Values have been steadily rising and the newest forecasts point to even more gains down the road. At the end of September, BMO Capital Markets published updated commodity…
Taxes and Tariffs and Trade: Oh My! Trump’s Plan to Bolster the Economy
by Just The News
In a bid to build a broader coalition, former President Donald Trump has outlined a vision of tax cuts, import tariffs, and “reciprocal trade” to preserve and restore American industries. Since coming down the escalator of Trump Tower in 2015, the Republican standard bearer has espoused unconventional trade policies and…
Expert Testimony: Mass Immigration Under Biden-Harris Is Driving Up Rents for Americans
by Breitbart
The arrival of millions of foreign nationals, many of whom are illegal aliens, under President Joe Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris is helping to drive up rents for working- and middle-class Americans, an expert witness told Congress Wednesday. Center for Immigration Studies Director of Research Steven Camarota told the…
This Year Marks First Since 1958 That Us Held No Oil and Gas Lease Sales
by Just The News
This year will be the first year since 1958 that the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management held no offshore oil and gas lease sales. Energy expert Alex Epstein, author of “Fossil Future,” argued at a recent House Budget Committee hearing the United States’ record-high oil production is in spite of…
Kamala’s Devastating Middle Class Taxes
by Independent Sentinel
With the election coming up, the IRS plans to reduce our taxes for 2025. it’s a common tactic to make it seem like they won’t tax us into oblivion once they return to office. CBS News: Some Americans could see lower federal income taxes in 2025 due to an annual…
Congress Passes Stop-Gap Spending Bill After Failed Mike Johnson Gambit
by Breitbart
Congress on Wednesday passed legislation that would fund the government through nearly the end of December. The House and the Senate passed a stop-gap spending bill that would push the government spending deadline to December 20. The measure, otherwise known as a continuing resolution (CR), keeps federal spending the same….
A ‘Bipartisan’ Bar Tried to Open in DC, Then Libs Cried That an Elephant Image Was ‘Hurtful.’
by The National Pulse
A new bar in Washington, D.C., whose political theme focused on bipartisan agreement and debate, succumbed to partisan pressure before the establishment could even serve its first drink. Originally billed as Political Pattie’s, the bar was flooded with complaints by liberals who said the establishment’s logo—specifically the Republican Elephant—was offensive…
Newsom Signs Bill Requiring Janitors to Take $200 Sexual Harassment Training
by Just The News
California Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a bill requiring companies that hire janitors to make sure janitors take sexual assault training every other year, and pay $200 per participant for sessions with under 10 janitors present, and $8 for sessions with 10 or more janitors. The bill also requires the government…
Biden-Harris Regime Prepares Another $8 Billion in Military Aid for Ukraine During Zelensky’s Washington Visit
by The Gateway Pundit
The Biden-Harris regime is once again prioritizing foreign interests over the well-being of American citizens, with plans to announce an eye-watering $8 billion in military aid for Ukraine during Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky’s visit to Washington. This massive giveaway comes as Americans continue to face economic hardships, skyrocketing inflation, and…
‘Economic Dystopia:’ Silicon Valley Tycoon Predicts AI Will Take Over 80% of All Work
by Breitbart
Vinod Khosla, legendary Silicon Valley investor and entrepreneur, has predicted that AI will replace the majority of work in most jobs, necessitating the implementation of universal basic income (UBI) to prevent economic instability and inequity. Fortune reports that in a recent blog post, Vinod Khosla, the billionaire co-founder of Sun…
